Neighborhood Pizza

Recommended. 7.3/10 for the pizza, however I'm still giving 5/5 stars overall for the restaurant. I ordered half cheese | half pepperoni, ham, meatball, sausage, bacon, ricotta. Crust: 24 hour fermentation, slightly undercooked on mine and mild flavor. 6.5/10. I will ask to cook a little longer next time as the pizza ordered by another patron looked perfectly cooked. Sauce: Perfect balance, very tasty that was fresh and vibrant with sweetness without being overpowering. The sauce is the star here. My diet rule is I eat 2 slices and the sauce here made me have 3. 10/10 Cheese + toppings: Quality ingredients. Cheese was not greasy, nor were any toppings. You can tell the bacon was very freshly cooked. Meatballs, ham, and ricotta were also very good. The ham was thicker which I enjoyed. I also really enjoyed the sliced meatball which I'm usually very picky on. Pepperoni was mild and I was not in love with the thinly sliced sausage as I felt it was overly mild. Personal preference here as I normally like bold and flavorful sausage. I also felt toppings were a bit sparse across each slice but understand you need to carefully balance to not overload a pizza. Plenty of ricotta however. 6.5/10. Size/Value: Large is a 16" (most chains call a 14" large and 16" XL). Well worth $16.99 for a cheese pizza and then $1 for each topping, which is the cheapest topping price I've seen in 30 years on a large pizza. Incredible pricing. (Bonus +.1) Very clean restaurant, including the bathroom. Service was very very good. Foam cups and paper plates. While I'm not going to penalty for the cups, I am going to penalty for the plates as this isn't a sufficient solution for pizza when dining in as the plates are susceptible to tearing (like mine did) if you eat pizza with a knife and fork like I do. I understand logistical benefits of paper plates but would like to see perhaps a different disposable option with more strength for silverware use. (Penalty -.1) The service really stood out here, despite younger girls running the show. Morgan was our server and we really appreciated her friendly service. Myla and Chloe were also very friendly. (Bonus +.1) Owners Ted and Kim are actively engaged and very sweet people. While the location is a little out of the way for some, it makes perfect sense for them as it's around the corner from home, including staff. I didn't mind the location. Local community members (Ted is a local Rotarian) who offer 10% veteran / police / fire discounts. I appreciated that they spoke well of other pizza restaurants, supporting the community. Ted mentioned while other places may do things differently, that there is room for everyone as they all have their niche. I really enjoyed talking with them. Very customer focused. Kim is from NJ (one of the pizza capitals) who pushed Ted to start this pizza venture. While he's been in the food industry, this is his first pizza business ownership. They use the industry standard Bakers Pride (quality) ovens. You may have had his food before as he does the cooking for the famous "Beast Feast". Looking forward to going back and trying their white pizza

This is a true neighborhood eatery! Quick and easy! Saves me from going into Inverness. Other than that the spaghetti and meat balls were fabulous! Delicious, fresh, and filling. The young waitress was very attentive and went out of her way to make sure the visit was a great experience! YES, I will be back!!!

Finally got to try Neighborhood Pizza yesterday and I am so glad I did. Ordered a Calzone with Spinach, mushrooms, and onions. Thin flaky crust, alot of cheese, and very fresh vegetables. Was very good sized. 1 of the best I've had around here. Service was extremely friendly and the place was very clean.If you haven't tried them yet you really need to.

Just get delivery going. If having Uber/door dash/grub hub/etc was really a disaster for other restaurants, the platforms would have failed and it wouldn't be a thing. You are the most convenient pizza place to the majority of residents here but you lose on the delivery side and your competitors are getting the bulk of your territory because you require customers to change a habit in order to enjoy your product. Come on guys. These are pizza biz basics. You can do it.

I heard so many awesome things about this new little pizza spot. I had to try it! I called in and got some for take out. Nice little place, super friendly people, and a short wait for a family take out meal. The pizza, the sub, the mozzarella sticks, and the calzone were beyond top notch. The sauce is what dreams are made of. If you’re looking for a place you haven’t tried yet, this is your sign!

This is my second visit, I first had the Italian sausage sandwich, great quality, and the amount was spot on. Then I've had one of their pizzas and it was incredible, the sauce has taste. Cooked to perfection. This is my new Italian place.. Kim is the owner along with her husband. She is a fantastic person. I believe this is a family-owned business, and even the young ones are kind and respectful which is a rarity. Check them out you will not be disappointed. Also the prices are very reasonable.

First time trying Neighborhood Pizza, called in an order for a small neighborhood pizza and a 12pc bbq wing. Pizza was fantastic no complaints, the wings were spot on as well. Will definitely go back. From the crust to the the toppings there wasn’t anything about this pizza not to love.

Neighborhood Pizza definitely lives up to its name - it has that cozy, welcoming vibe you want from a local spot. The wings were surprisingly great — crispy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The Buffalo chicken pizza was really good - just the right balance of spice (not super spicy). The atmosphere was great, and the service was genuinely wonderful - friendly, attentive, and fast without feeling rushed. Definitely our new go-to pizza spot.